Local Insurance Agent Serving Taylor, PA — Without the Drive to Scranton

Taylor residents deserve straightforward insurance coverage from someone who knows Lackawanna County — not a call center that doesn't.

Minimal black corner line drawing on a white background

Auto and Home Insurance for Taylor Residents, Compared Across Carriers

As an independent agency, we're not tied to a single insurance company. That means when you call us about auto or home insurance in Taylor, we compare rates across multiple carriers to find coverage that fits your situation — not just the first price that comes up. If you already have a policy, we'll review it at no cost to see whether you're paying more than you should be. When was the last time someone actually checked your rate?

 

  • Auto insurance quotes compared across multiple carriers
  • Home insurance for Taylor homeowners, including older residential properties
  • Renters insurance for Taylor tenants — often more affordable than people expect
  • Free policy reviews with no obligation to switch

Serving Taylor from Avoca — Close Enough to Call, Close Enough to Visit

Our office is in Avoca, just a short drive from Taylor borough. But for most of what you need — a quote, a policy review, a question about your coverage — a phone call or text message handles it. You shouldn't have to rearrange your day to get good insurance service. Call us, text us, or stop in. We work around your schedule.

Small black right-angle corner lines on a mostly blank white background

What our clients have to say

Testimonials

GOOGLE REVIEWS

Five black stars on a white background
Black quotation marks icon in bold, stylized design
Black check mark inside a circular outline on a white background.

Does Bundling Auto and Home Insurance Actually Save Money in Taylor?

It depends on your specific policies and carriers — and we'll show you the actual numbers before you commit to anything. Bundling can reduce your combined premium, but it isn't always the right move for every household. We run the quotes both ways, compare the totals, and give you a straight answer. If bundling saves you money, we'll tell you. If it doesn't, we'll tell you that too.

 

  • Side-by-side comparison of bundled vs. separate policy premiums
  • No pressure to combine coverage unless the math supports it
  • One point of contact for both your auto and home policies
Black map location pin icon on a white background

Over 35 Years Serving Families Across Lackawanna County

Carey Insurance has been locally and family-owned since 1989. We've built our reputation across the Scranton–Wilkes-Barre corridor by treating clients like neighbors — because most of them are. Our 4.8-star Google rating reflects more than 100 reviews from real policyholders across the region who found us responsive, honest, and easy to work with. We've received ERIE Life Recognition Awards and Founders' Awards, and we're active members of the Old Forge Lions and Sons of Italy.

Questions from Taylor Residents About Insurance Coverage

  • Do I need to come into the office to get a quote for auto or home insurance in Taylor?

    No. Most quotes and policy reviews are handled entirely by phone or text. If you prefer to meet in person, our Avoca office is a short drive from Taylor borough — but it's rarely necessary.

  • How does an independent insurance agent differ from going directly to one carrier?

    An independent agent like Carey Insurance works with multiple insurance companies, which means we compare rates and coverage options on your behalf. Going directly to a single carrier gives you only that company's pricing. We give you options.

  • Is renters insurance worth it for someone renting in Taylor?

    For most renters, yes. Renters insurance covers your personal belongings, provides liability protection, and is typically one of the more affordable policies available. Many Taylor renters are surprised by how low the monthly cost is relative to what it covers.

  • Can you review my current auto insurance policy even if I didn't buy it through Carey Insurance?

    Yes, and we do it at no cost. Bring your current policy or declarations page and we'll compare it against what's available through our carriers. If we find a better rate or stronger coverage, we'll show you the difference. If your current policy is competitive, we'll tell you that too.

  • What types of insurance does Carey Insurance offer to Taylor residents?

    We offer a full range of personal insurance lines, including auto, home, renters, life, motorcycle, and recreational vehicle coverage. We also work with small business owners in the area who need commercial coverage.

Ready to Talk Insurance in Taylor? We're a Call Away.

Getting a quote or reviewing your current coverage takes less time than you'd expect. Call us at 570-451-3808, send a text for a callback, or submit a request online. We offer free quotes, same-day estimates, and straight answers — no hold queues, no pressure.

Medicare Made Easy for Lyndon Residents

If you’re nervous about making the wrong Medicare choice, you’re not alone. We walk you through every step—clearly explaining your options, verifying your doctors, reviewing prescriptions, and ensuring deadlines are met.


No guesswork. Just answers.